A business plan with a few bugs in it

Behind the Headlines
Former U.S. president Bill Clinton with the winning team (from left to right): Jesse Pearlstein, Shobhita Soor, Zev Thompson, Gabriel Mott and Mohammed Ashour.(Photo: Mark Von Holden/AP Images for Hult Prize)

Former U.S. president Bill Clinton with the Hult Prize winning team from McGill (from left to right) Jesse Pearlstein, Shobhita Soor, Zev Thompson, Gabriel Mott and Mohammed Ashour (Photo: Mark Von Holden/AP Images)

by Jennifer Nault

For many people, the opportunity to share a stage with former U.S. president Bill Clinton would qualify as the thrill of a lifetime. For others, the chance to receive million dollar support to make their business plans a reality, would constitute the same. A group of McGill students recently managed to experience both things on the very same night.

On September 23 in New York City, Clinton made an announcement at the Clinton Global Initiative that would profoundly affect the lives of Mohammed Ashour, Gabriel Mott, Shobhita Soor, BSc’10, Jesse Pearlstein and Zev Thompson. The five were named as the winners of the 2013 Hult Prize Challenge.

The $1-million prize invites MBA students from around the globe to solve the world’s most critical global challenges, providing seed money to encourage the next generation of social entrepreneurs. The competition is stiff. In fact, more than 11,000 applicants from 150 different countries submitted entries for this year’s competition, which bills itself as the “start-up accelerator for social entrepreneurship.”

Every year there is a new theme, and the 2013 challenge required entrants to find solutions to enhance food security for undernourished communities and solve the global food crisis. “To be competitive at the Hult Prize against other top business schools, we knew we needed something revolutionary. We decided on insects. Once we did some preliminary research we knew we had our idea,” said Mott in an interview with the Globe and Mail.

In the Boston regional competition held this spring, McGill beat out Harvard, MIT and Yale based on the merits of their plan to produce and promote insects – or what they call “micro-livestock” – as an innovative protein source.

Back then, the McGill team was still at the conceptual phase of their business plan; they believed their business model could be implemented within urban slums, which would have meant raising insects within those inner-city zones.

However, plans change. “Now we are moving operations to more ‘peri-urban rural areas,’” says Soor. “We’ve done more research since the regionals, and so we’re being informed by conditions on the ground. We’re still looking to serve the urban slum market, but we’ve made a shift based on the observation that the infrastructure is just not there in urban slums.”

As a result of their investigations, locations peripheral to urban areas are currently being sought out as places to raise micro-livestock. “We learned that people migrating into the big cities – into slum areas – they are trying to distance themselves from growing their own food, from farming.”

They settled on Puebla, located about 120 kilometres southeast of Mexico City. Right now, the team is taking advantage of the grasshopper season in Mexico. “We have operations and an employee based in Puebla, and we are currently harvesting large numbers of grasshoppers to begin our breeding colonies. In a few weeks’ time, two of us will be travelling to Mexico to begin production there. A couple of months after that, we’ll begin production in Ghana – we’re building relationships there right now,” says Soor.

Soor is the lone law student in the group. Mott, Pearlstein and Thompson are all MBA students, while Ashour is working on a joint MBA-medical degree.

With team members balancing their studies at McGill with their business plans, they will need all the extra protein they can get to push themselves into the production phase. No problem there. “Crickets are packed with nutrients, especially protein, which people living in urban slums lack. Millions of people around the world already eat insects and the solution is to get them to eat even more, in a way that is both sustainable and reliable. If fed the right diet, crickets contain eight times more iron than beef,” says Thompson.

Ashour, who ate crickets this spring on a live television broadcast, calls them the “shrimp of the next decade.” Speaking with the Globe and Mail, Mott listed off an array of culinary creatures they’d tried: “Fried crickets taste slightly like buttery almonds, with a bit of an aftertaste. Fried in chilies and lime, however, they taste like those ingredients, and baked into a chip they are all but undetectable. Zev Thompson had grasshoppers in tacos and sauces in Mexico and found them spicy. Shobhita Soor had caterpillars in Thailand and found them savoury and sweet.”

When presenting the prize to the McGill team, Clinton declared, “If I said to somebody 60 days ago I’m going to give this prize this year to someone who wants to process and sell edible insects — to empower rather than devour — they’d have laughed.”

McGill’s Hult Prize champions will be participating in a McGill Homecoming event on October 18 at 3 pm organized by the Desautels Faculty of Management’s Social Economy Initiative. Also taking part will be the four past winners of McGill’s Dobson Cup Social Enterprise Track. It’s an opportunity to find out how social entrepreneurs are changing the world. RSVP to reserve a seat.

 

Share this article:

Comments

15 Responses to “A business plan with a few bugs in it”
  1. Donna Davis says:

    I hope this initiative and award will represent a genuine step forward in a paradigm shift–across the world, across all cultures, societies, and economic classes–from the consumption of vertebrate protein to that of insects and other organisms lower on the food chain. The ethical, philosophical and environmental impact of this change could hardly be overestimated.
    We, Easter Islanders all, have taken for reality–intransigent reality–what is in fact symbolic, ideological, and mythological, our common-sense assumptions and resistances destroying the biosphere and propagating terrific cruelties as if no alternatives were possible.
    Perhaps one day we may even relish the taste of crickets as crickets, not disguised in or as other familiar foods. And–like the Canada geese culled from the New York airports and intended for distribution to the “poor”–if a food source is fit for “human” consumption, that means for EVERYONE.

  2. Mohamed Smaoui says:

    You guys rock! I’ll be looking forward to a meal of crickets!

  3. T.K.Raghunathan says:

    There must be more intelligent ways for humans to survive than en masse killing of other sentient beings. I certainly do not feel elated as a human being, much less as an ex-McGill.

  4. S Yohannes says:

    Yet another example of the elite trying to save the world. If this has not been asked for by the communities they are working in it will not be sustainable. Change happens from within, this is true on an individual basis and on a community basis. I would rather see this approach used in western culture, because it is the dominant minority culture that needs to change, not the people they are trying to “help”.

    • Jake says:

      Hey S Yohannes!

      Check out Future Food Salon: alimentaryinitiatives.com/future-food-salon-manhattan/#future-food-salon-cricket-anyone

      Coming to montreal very very soon :-)

  5. Sharon says:

    I find it interesting that there are two species of crickets that are kosher, ancient wisdom written and permitted (Torah), so as far as the shrimp of the future, they’d be okay to eat. Are these the type used in the plan? Go figure. Wonder what the blessing would be. Are they halal as well? Crick-o-ritos the latest flavour; Bon appetite!

  6. Lauran Unzueta says:

    McGill got it’s prize and is now getting it’s acclaim. It’s a bittersweet victory for my alma mater however, knowing that the University has thrown one of it’s own PhD research’s and all his hard work under the bus. I hope the Jakub Dzamba will get some measure of a decent settlement with the Hult Team and McGill. Not only in repayment for his research and efforts unacknowledged by the Hult team, but also so he can continue going with his work.

  7. Yvonne Hilder says:

    As a McGill alumna I am outraged that the hard work of Jakub Dzamba — which goes back years, has not been properly acknowledged by the winning team, the Hult Prize and of course my Alma Mater. Step up McGill — we are all watching!

  8. A says:

    The idea was clearly stolen from Kubo Dzamba. Disgusting display of plagiarism, I guess this demonstrates that the “winners” are not innovative thinkers rather are criminal minded sociopaths. And the Hult prize is made to celebrate this?? I would never support or ever do business with these types.

    http://www.mcgill.ca/architecture/news

    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/mcgill-student-on-sidelines-as-former-team-wins-1-million-entrepreneurial-prize/article14512498/

    http://www.montrealgazette.com/business/McGill+students+turn+insect+farming+into+million/8944685/story.html

  9. Fan Zhang says:

    As a previous classmate of Jakub, we witnessed his research on this matter way before his phd at McGill. It is the university’s responsibility to investigate in this plagiarism issue, and bring justice to your student’s work. If you can’t even do that, not only will we be very disappointed, you have no right to demand scholar integrity from any of your students.

  10. Monica says:

    I love the idea. I think it is incredible. I thought it was a an incredibly great idea when it was presented to me by Jakub Dzamba a few years ago. I have been following his work at McGill for the last couple of years and to see this group win, knowing that they took information and used Jakub’s expertise on this is awful. This is plagiarism at its worst and I hope McGill and the Hult prize are able to take some steps to remedy this situation. Jakub has worked too hard and long for them to get away with using him. I beg you to look into this matter and give Jakub the intellectual credit he deserves.

  11. Patricia says:

    Interesting ideas….as long as those of us in the wealthy countries are willing to make the change as well.